Contractor Insurance You Can Trust
Can I Get Workers Comp with a Prior Claim?
Yes — prior claims don’t disqualify you from coverage. But they affect your EMR, your carrier options, and your premium. Here’s how to navigate it.
- ✓Prior claims raise your EMR and may shift you to non-standard markets
- ✓Documentation of safety improvements improves underwriting outcomes
- ✓E&S carriers specialize in contractors with claims history
- ✓Time improves all outcomes — claims age out of the EMR in three years
✓ 20+ Years Experience
✓ Same-Day COI
✓ Licensed All 50 States
Or call (234) 231-8427 — Mon–Fri, 9 AM–5 PM EST
How Prior Claims Affect Your Coverage Options
Workers comp carriers evaluate prior claims through your experience modification rate (EMR) and through submitted loss runs — detailed reports of all claims from the past 3-5 years. A single significant claim may raise your EMR to 1.15 or 1.20. Multiple claims may push it to 1.40 or higher.
Standard admitted carriers typically accept contractors with EMRs up to about 1.25. Above that, you start moving into the non-admitted (E&S) market, where carriers specialize in riskier accounts and price them accordingly. Coverage is available — just at a higher rate.
A catastrophic single claim — a fatality, severe disability, or multiple hospitalizations — may require underwriting review regardless of your overall EMR. Carriers want to understand the circumstances and what changed to prevent recurrence.
Presenting Your Risk Effectively
When seeking coverage after a significant claim, prepare a submission package that includes loss runs, a written explanation of the significant claim(s), and documentation of what changed afterward. Safety program implementation, return-to-work policy adoption, and management changes are all relevant.
Carriers understand that accidents happen. What they’re evaluating is whether you’ve taken the claim seriously and reduced the likelihood of recurrence. A claim followed by zero claims for two years tells a very different story than a claim followed by additional claims.
We present your risk narrative to carriers in a way that maximizes your competitive positioning. The difference between a cold submission and a well-packaged risk can be 10–20% in the quoted premium from the same carrier.
Prior Claims Don’t Have to Mean High Premiums Forever
We work in non-standard markets and know how to present your risk to get competitive quotes even with prior claim history.